Member-only story
My issues with Jordan Peterson’s views on religion and God
Jordan Peterson, prominent Canadian psychology lecturer, author and internet phenomenon, recently went head-to-head with neuroscientist and public atheist Sam Harris, in a series of four debates held by Pangburn Philosophy. Peterson frequents public forums such as Joe Rogan’s ‘The Joe Rogan Experience’ and Dave Rubin’s ‘The Rubin Report.’
Peterson has also been touring his hugely successful book tour for his novel ’12 Rules for Life.’ Harris, on the other hand has his own podcast ‘Waking up with Sam Harris,’ as well as several successful novels.
The recent debates between the two intellectual juggernauts spanned roughly eight hours, and you can read my summary of the debates here.
However, what I wish to address in this piece specifically are my issues with Peterson’s views on God and religion.
After scouring the comments sections of YouTube, it is easy to notice the litany of criticism laid upon Harris for having too simplistic a conception of God.
Conversely, Peterson receives his fair share of criticism, most of which argues that his definition of God is too vague or inconsistent. I agree with the latter, hence the title of the piece.
Harris, in the opening statements of the first debate described himself in a way which struck a chord with me. He described seeing himself as “the problem.” What Harris meant, and where I agree with him, is in seeing the wisdom of Peterson. I have listened to countless hours of Peterson lectures and have a great deal of admiration for him. On almost every topic I find myself either agreeing with him or learning from him in some way. And yet, as Harris mentions, a line is crossed where Peterson no longer maintains this ability over me.
That line is religion.
Initially I simply presumed I wasn’t fully grasping what Peterson meant about God, spirituality or his views on religion, because when Peterson spoke on such issues I honestly couldn’t really get what he was saying. Peterson has a notoriously well-loaded vernacular, making him a force in…
